Society Says Carp Fence Is Good First Step For Smelly, Dirty Lagoon

An environmental group is supporting efforts by The District of Coldstream to improve the water quality in the Kalavista Lagoon.

The Society For the Protection of Kalamalka Lake did a baseline study of the murky and often smelly, water body on the east side of Kalamalka Lake by Kalavista Drive near Alexander’s Pub.

One part of the study focused on minnow trapping and seine netting which organizers say revealed “an abundance of juvenile non-salmonid fish species, with over 4,300 fish from nine different species.”

“A noteworthy capture was the chiselmouth chub, a blue-listed (vulnerable) species known to inhabit Okanagan Lake but not previously reported in Kalamalka Lake.
Approximately 60 large common carp were observed in the lagoon in May. Common carp are an introduced species known to alter shallow lakes and ponds across North America by uprooting vegetation as they feed. The lack of plant roots to bind the sediment in the Kalavista Lagoon results in cloudy water when waves, waterfowl or carp disturb the water column,” says Simone Runyan, the project lead.

The District plans to install an experimental fence in the lagoon canal this year to prevent carp from entering the lagoon, which the group says should allow aquatic plants to regrow and reduce turbidity.

24/7 Supervised Care

Conservative Health Critic issues call for answers in the Vernon hit-and-run death

3h ago

Ramp Up Military Camp Use

Mayor wants federal military spending in Vernon

8h ago

Climate-Related Project Guidance

Vernon reviewing Climate Action Plan

21h ago

“The fence is “step one” of several possible steps including sediment removal, bank stabilization and fencing to deter geese, which could help to reduce odour and improve lagoon water quality, paddling opportunities and wildlife habitat in the lagoon. SPrKL is interested in observing the effects of the carp exclusion fence on lagoon water quality and hopes that the fence will serve their mission: “to preserve and protect the quality and health of Kalamalka Lake Watershed for all future generations,” adds Runyan, from Kestrel Ecological Consultants.

The group plans to seek funding for follow-up monitoring of lagoon water quality from the Okanagan Basin Water Board.

The study also raised concerns about the future of the turtles that make the lagoon their home.

“In 2017, a total of 18 western painted turtles were counted, but in 2018, only 13 turtles were counted, despite additional field visits,” says Runyan. “Western painted turtles are a blue-listed species that has lost much habitat; over 84% of low elevation wetlands within the Okanagan and Similkameen Valleys have already been lost due to development. The Kalavista Lagoon has become so shallow that soon turtles may be unable to overwinter there successfully. Sediment vacuuming could be used to deepen some areas.”

You can read more about the study in the news release below.

KALAVISTA LAGOON BASELINE STUDY COMPLETED (news release)

Coldstream, BC, March 29, 2019 – The Society for the Protection of Kalamalka Lake (SPrKL) conducted a baseline study of the Kalavista Lagoon, a 1-acre pond across from Alexander’s Pub, in the spring, summer and fall of 2018.

The results suggest measures for improving the lagoon as wildlife habitat and for the enjoyment of the community.

Coldstream Council and staff are taking action this spring with the installation of a carp exclusion fence.

With funding of $4,390 from the Okanagan Basin Water Board (OBWB) and $14,300 from the District of Coldstream, three consulting companies voluntarily reduced their rates by 50% and worked together to complete the in-depth study. Allen Hanson of Triton Environmental Consultants assessed the fish and fish habitat of the lagoon. Trina Koch and Gina LeBel of Western Water Associates conducted water quality and sediment analyses. Simone Runyan of Kestrel Ecological Consultants acted as project lead,
and inventoried lagoon wildlife and wildlife habitat, including aquatic and terrestrial plants, bathymetry, aquatic invertebrate sampling and adult carp enumeration. Caro Analytical also generously reduced their laboratory fees, and Michael Miller, Ph.D., a local plant biologist with LGL Ltd. Consulting, assisted
with identification of aquatic vegetation pro bono.

Minnow trapping and seine netting revealed an abundance of juvenile non-salmonid fish species (over 4,300 fish from nine different species). A noteworthy capture was the chiselmouth chub, a blue-listed (vulnerable) species known to inhabit Okanagan Lake but not previously reported in Kalamalka Lake. Approximately 60 large common carp were observed in the lagoon in May. Common carp are an introduced species known to alter shallow lakes and ponds across North America by uprooting vegetation as they feed. The lack of plant roots to bind the sediment in the Kalavista Lagoon results in cloudy water when waves, waterfowl or carp disturb the water column.

Caro Analytical’s water quality analysis showed hyper-eutrophic water with excessive phosphorous (the likely cause of an algae bloom in July). High E. coli levels, especially in August, were due in part to an abundance of waterfowl. Elevated turbidity (cloudiness) in May was likely worsened by the spawning and feeding activities of carp.

Sediment cores showed that 1 to 1.5 meters of sediment had accumulated since the lagoon was created as a water feature in Coldstream’s first subdivision in the late 1940s, 70 years ago. Laboratory analyses indicated that the sediments contained levels of heavy metals (above guideline thresholds), likely due to historic agricultural practices and urban contamination.

In 2017, a total of 18 western painted turtles were counted, but in 2018, only 13 turtles were counted, despite additional field visits. Western painted turtles are a blue-listed species that has lost much habitat; over 84% of low elevation wetlands within the Okanagan and Similkameen Valleys have already been lost due to development. The Kalavista Lagoon has become so shallow that soon turtles may be unable to overwinter there successfully. Sediment vacuuming could be used to deepen some areas.

This spring, using a design produced by Associated Environmental Consultants and Kerr Wood Leidal Consulting Engineers, the District of Coldstream plans to install an experimental fence in the lagoon canal to prevent carp from entering the lagoon. Over a few years, aquatic plants may then regrow, stabilizing the lagoon sediment and reducing turbidity. The fence is “step one” of several possible steps including sediment removal, bank stabilization and fencing to deter geese, which could help to reduce odour and improve lagoon water quality, paddling opportunities and wildlife habitat in the lagoon. SPrKL is interested in observing the effects of the carp exclusion fence on lagoon water quality and hopes that the fence will serve their mission: “to preserve and protect the quality and health of Kalamalka Lake Watershed for all future generations.”Funding for follow-up monitoring of lagoon water quality is being sought from the OBWB.

The Kalavista Lagoon Baseline Environmental Assessment 2018 is available in draft form as part of the District of Coldstream agenda for February 19, 2019 (Appendix F). The final report will also be available on the SPrKL website at www.spkl.ca. Please contact Simone Runyan at kestrel.ecological@gmail.com for further information.

The Society for the Protection of Kalamalka Lake www.spkl.ca
Mission Statement: To preserve and protect the quality and health of Kalamalka Lake Watershed for all future generations so that the lake may be enjoyed by all user groups in an environmentally sustainable manner.